Is There Pain?
It is hard to do research without causing at least a little pain, right?
Well, in What Will Ease the Pain? Ask a Frog, studies are
being conducted by Craig W. Stevens, a pharmacologist at the Oklahoma State
University College of Osteopathic Medicine in Tulsa, to find test subjects
that feel less discomfort. In his studies he has found what he believes
to be the first nonmammal “guinea pig” for analgesis, the leopard frog.
In Stevens’ study he places a drop of vinegar on a frog’s thigh and watches
for a characteristic wiping response, which would indicate that there is
irritation. If this doesn’t occur he keep placing drops on the opposite
thigh until the frog finally attempts to wipe it off. Then after
doing all of this he delivers an analgesic drug to the animal and runs
this test again.
The reason Stevens conducted this test was to contrast humans, which have
3 types of brain receptor for pain-inhibiting opiate drugs, to frogs which
only possess 1. What Stevens found was that frog’s receptors respond
to drugs and work on any of the 3 human receptors and the potency of analgesics
in frogs match that of mammals. So how is this important to research?
Stevens believes that with further studies of these amphibians “eventually
will lead to a better understanding of the molecular mechanisms of how
opiates work.” (J.R., 1999)
Did you know that a test can be considered to be an alternative and still
use animals?
Well that is a very important fact that those who are for animal testing
can and do bring up and this isn’t their only argument against alternatives.
For one thing according to Animal Testing by Angel, animal testing supporters
can argue alot about computers and technology and how they can never duplicate
some situations. They say if that could be done science would be
way more advanced and they would have found many cures by now. Another
argument deals with the fact that computers do have downfalls and the person
who had made up this program still had to test on animals. So how
is this reducing animal testing? These are just some interesting
facts about alternatives. To read more about this topic click
here.
There are many institutes that are non-profit, technology driven foundations
that are primarily dedicated to the advancement of alternative methods
to animal testing. To check out a very popular foundation that is
dedicated to stopping animal cruelty and developing new alternative click
on the following: Institute
for In Vitro Sciences.
This
page was made by Stacy Kohle, a student at Wayne
State College, on April 20, 1999. If you have any questions or
comments e-mail me at stkohl02@willy.wsc.edu.